Reviewing a re-imagining of Tomb of Horrors is a bit complicated…and it doesn’t help that the modules been out for some weeks now (or years, depending on which version of Tomb of Horrorsyou’re reading). The task of writing this review has sort of opened up, a kind of question of game philosophy, game direction, and game history, with an emphasis in all three on motive. I say this because I think that ToH is perhaps the most iconic of Dungeons and Dragons modules. It, more than any other module, demonstrated to enterprising and imaginative DMs the possibilities for adventures available within the game.
Now, that’s a bold statement. So, let me back this up. Obviously, the series of modules devoted to the drow and to the slave lords are oft cited as iconic, as is Keep on the Borderlands (which I think is the most recognizable adventure of all), but each of these adventures concentrated on immersion, story line…the primary thing you remember about these adventures was not that they tested the boundaries of what one could do with the Dungeons and Dragons game but provided good standard for a normal D and D adventure.
Let me try this another way, most adventures taught DMs what an adventure in a fantasy setting ought to look like (dungeon crawl, cavern exploration, fortress assault, encounter with evil civilization, etc.). The S series of modules did something more. They actively stretched the bounds of the DMs function in the game. They acted as an example of what you could do in D and D that might otherwise have escaped your attention. Lost Caverns of Tsojcath said to DMs, “hey, this is what an adventure looks like when the majority of the creatures are custom made.” It even instructed DMs a bit about how to create custom creatures from thin air and make them balanced to their encounter. Mind you, this kind of thinking was in its earliest stages: it provided examples, not a rubric for game mechanics—but it was like designer’s permission to start making custom monsters.
White Plume (the lamest of the S series) basically explained how to put the menagerie of D and D beasties all in one place, how to create encounters from extremely disparate creatures. Outside the White Plume Philosophy, you’re in a module based on giants, and you fight giants. You’re in a module based on slavers and you fight slavers. In White Plume, the next room could as easily have had a dragon as a treant and White Plume provided a great example of how such an adventure could be designed logically.
Expedition to the BarrierPeaks stretched the definition of fantasy setting as far as it could go by changing the dungeon into a space ship. Forget game balance. Expedition balanced itself against itself. The weapons it gave out were fair only inside the module. Outside the shell of the ship, a character with any of those weapons was unstoppable. Ignoring that for a moment though, Expedition was the module that really said that anything goes, and meant it.
…But more than any others stood the Tomb of Horrors, S1, the first of the series which said to the clever DM, the puzzler and the trap maker, this is how you do it. As far as the craziness of 1st edition is concerned, it is Tomb of Horrors that set the standard for setting up a module that would challenge the veteran adventurer and the power gamer alike.
The thing is, though, Tomb of Horrors is, by all that is standard game philosophy in 4e, the worst module ever made. It is horrible from the point of view of 4e because it does EVERYTHING that 4e tells you that you should never do as a DM. One must ask, then, how does one moves from the best 1e module (and the worst 4e module) to what is, in my opinion, a shoddy remake (because a remake of Tomb of Horrors is, otherwise, impossible) and yet, still produce the best 4e module thus far? By answering this question in regards to the iconic status of ToH, I would like to try to explain the preconceptions of the various editions, and why edition was ever needed in the first place.
Stay tuned, more to come…
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment