In older versions of Dungeons and Dragons, non-combat tasks, like combat roles now, fell neatly into classes. The fighters carried all the loot, the magic users performed all the weird magic stuff, the clerics did all the healing, and the thieves handled the traps. Well, now the fighters aren't always super strong (though most of them still are), about half the classes can cast rituals (which are the spells that matter), anyone can heal, and traps...well, traps are the unspoken left out problem with the game. Though they are still as prevalent as monsters or puzzles, they require much more specific abilities tohandle. As the system stands now, perception finds the trap and thievery disables, but no one (maybe not even the Rogue) really concentrates on thievery. In fourth edition, spotting traps has become much easier than in previous editions but getting rid of the trap, or getting experience from the trap is much more difficult.
Here's the thing you should take into account: traps are still a big part of the game. This means that the characters will probably run into traps and without a chance to handle them, they will likely lose precious healing surges for each trap they encounter. With a character proficient in thievery (often a Rogue) each trap becomes a chance to earn experience on a single die roll (experience comparable to killing a monster which requires many many more die rolls and generally more damage). At the same time, if the roll fails and the trap goes off, the situation is no worse for having attempted to disarm, but is pretty much equal to what would have happened without a character proficient in thievery. So, the thievery skill is all, in and of itself, a win-win: it creates opportunities for experience and prevents the loss of healing surges.
The problem is, however, that as far as strikers go, rogues aren't really top of the list and rogues are the most likely to put points into the thievery skill. Rogues as a class aren't bad, of course,but bararians, rangers, warlocks, etc., simply edge them out. Most parties, then, are left with strikers to cover the combat role of the rogue, but no one to cover the non-combat role of disarming traps.
This means that as a DM, you often have total control over how many healing surges the party has at any time if they have no rogue. Simply throw a trap at your party and they will have nothing they can do to disarm it. Through perception, they have a chance of avoiding a trap, but they won't go up in level for doing this, and that's the best they can hope for. Otherwise, you're simply taking healing surges away from them so as to adjust the difficulty of the next encounter. This is useful in a sense, but also counterproductive. A DM can ONLY throw a trap at the characters to reduce their healing surges since nothing about the traps can provoke an interesting party response. At best, you're inviting characters to put unseemly ammount of attention on perception since Perception is far more useful than thievery given the variety of situations that require a perception roll.
My advice for a group of players trying to organize a party is that you should realize that the character with the highest thieving skill will automatically become the thief during play and will most likely take the most damage from traps because of failed disarm attempts. The best idea, then, is for a party to draw its would-be thief from defenders or to make sure that character who is going to be acting the thief has the capacity to do so. I find that more often than not, groups of characters will have too many characters with high arcane, religion, or diplomacy scores. So that multiple characters can barter with a merchant, but no one can stop a pendulum from slicing them for 23 points of damage. I would suggest that while it's always a good idea to spread skills around between party members, do not neglect the thief skill assuming that someone will be playing a rogue.
My advice for the DM is to, by all means, keep up the traps. Enough of them enountered and the party will realize that someone needs to have a high score in thievery. At the same time, it can often be difficult to justify research between adventures, and traps may answer your problems there. The characters aren't likely to consult sages to find out that the dungeon there about to go into has an Owlbear, because...what do you do differently knowing there's an owlbear coming up, but if the characters learn the schematics of the intricate trap on the wizard's front door, then they'll be far more inclined towards research.
A tip here: a trap the characters learn about is a trap the characters don't have to worry about (and you don't have to worry about in terms of killing them all off). Behind the scenes, research can be made to seem more valuable than it really is. If the characters find out that the first room has something reminescent of Grimtooth (those of you who know, know), then they can avoid it, and they'll be really really glad they paid for the research. Plus, you'll look like you play for keeps without actually killing off half the party (which is no fun for anyone). On the other hand, if they don't do the research, they won't know that you've taken that trap out. Think of it as Schrodinger's Grimtooth. Just make sure to make research actually useful as well on top.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment