The three major complaints people seem to have with 4e (people who are not, necessarily, me) concern its radical revision of the magic system, its lack of variation in play between encounters, and the implication of this edition that yet another edition will follow to make everything players know about the game obsolete (again). I could be more specific, but I think that most problems people cite fall into one of these three categories. When I say that NToH suffers from the worst problems of fourth edition, and I say also that it is a showcase module, I am suggesting that it tends to accentuate these particular edition problems, even as it represents the bleeding edge of what can be done with 4e.
To make my point clearer, I am going to go out on a limb and say that most of the NToH’s problems could be solved by either removing Acererak from its adventures or severely limiting his role in the narrative as it stands. I realize that this is the strangest thing one could say about a Tomb of Horror adventure. I realize that I am saying that a remake of Tomb of Horrors ought not to include its most recognizable personality or that this personality might take a secondary role. I realize this seems absurd. Hear me out.
The problem isn't Acererak himself per se; it's the very idea of the demi-lich and that creature’s place in 4e. A lich was, in life, an ultra-powerful wizard. In death, it is a creature capable of bending time and space to his or her will. It knows powerful entities and can force them to do its bidding. Through that power, in life, it founded kingdoms and empires which it means to keep in death. By all evidence, Acererak of OToH was a being of immeasurable magical and political power and his tomb was like that of the pharaohs, a place of tricks and traps in which the great lich king could safely control his empire.
But the centuries wore on. The kingdom began to fail and fade. The lich king could not keep his political conquests together and so, slowly, the mighty empire fell into ruins. Its peoples dispersed, its architecture reclaimed by the jungle swamp. Acererak is like a 5th generation vampire from the game Vampire. Every plan he has takes 400 years to unfold. He isn't in a hurry. He can wait for his mortal enemies to die off. That's why a magician becomes a lich: so that they have the luxury of taking their own damned sweet time.
Sadly, eventually, time has its revenge. The lich is locked away in his tomb. His world crumbles around him and is replaced by a world that first tells legends of his greatness, which fade over the decades and centuries into silence. Now he is alone with his mysteries, unable to die, unable to really call what he has "life". He sits and waits out the eternity he’s bought with his magic. His friends die off. His enemies die off. That's why there aren't very many monsters in the original ToH--they all perished long ago...And Acererak comes to a point where the only thing that can make him feel anything at all is the possibility of his own demise. That's why he starts putting up cryptic riddles at the front door of his tomb as helpful hints to would-be raiders. NToH explains these riddles away as the result of insanity. No. Acererak isn't crazy. He's terminally bored.
This is an accurate description of a lich save one thing: Acererak isn't a lich; he's a demi lich--he's what happens when even that gets old! This was perfect for the OToH because the module is built around the idea of excavating a tomb of prehistoric evil. He is before the world of Greyhawk in which he is interred. Even the dragons don't remember his name.
Now, really give that some thought. The demi-lich is an extraordinarily passive villain. Basically, he lives in a place that used to be powerful, long ago, and if you happen to crawl into that hole, woe unto you. But if you don't, you're safe. OToH, as deadly as it was, wasn't pressingly deadly. You could stop any time, crawl your way back out unharrassed, recoup, heal, memorize new spells, whatever. A demi-lich isn't really going to come looking for you. That's the kind of villain a demi-lich is and isn’t.
Now, the villain of NToH is great. He is a necromancer and he's done something that I personally didn't think possible: he's come up with a new necromancer plot. Do we all understand how hard that is? The evil necromancer is a horrible cliché. And yet, with NToH, Marmell and Gray have produced an original and quite compelling plot surrounding necromancy. It’s amazing. They deserve applause. There’s just one problem: it's not a demi-lich plot. Does anything about Acererak in NToH suggest prehistoric evil? Is this the kind of adventure with a creature laying in wait? No on both counts; the villain just plain shouldn't be a demi-lich.
The presence of Acererak in an adventure that doesn’t really feel like a fight against a demi-lich feeds into complaints about 4e’s lack of variety. This is the same complaint one often hears that, no matter what's being fought, the combat is the same, and that the lack of interesting powers has now made the monsters interchangeable. I don't subscribe to this as an inevitable consequence of 4e, but I do see it as a compelling problem that DMs must, now, actively avoid, and Acererak in NToH has this problem. It's as if there was a monster called Generic Big Bad Guy, and he/she/it just gets reskinned with the result that solo dragons, evil demons, elemental princes, and liches all act pretty much the same way. You see it on a lesser level with the almost random manner in which monsters are packed together into an encounter. At one release day, I fought a quickling, a dire bear, and a pair of trogolodytes. By what logic are some of these creatures gathered? A: they’re monsters, they’re individual and particular natures just get in the way. It’s better not to think about what demi-liches do and do not do. They’re just beasts. Acererak is just a BBG.
In fact, look at Acererak a bit more closely and you'll see the template by which BBGs are designed in 4e. Don’t get me wrong, the involved history of Acererak at the beginning of NToH is a perfect example of how to plug a villain into the campaign’s various forces to make it belong. Nonetheless, the secret history comes off less like a fantasy biography and more like the background of a supervillain. Fine, except that I don't want Dr. Doom--I want Acererak the demi-lich. I don't need to know about Acererak and his dealings with some Orcus cult or some old Tiefling empire. The tablets on which the background of Acererak are written should have long gone to dust; that's what makes the immortality of a demi-lich so truly horrifying.
But there's more to it than just that. Let me rap grognard for a moment here--way back in the way way back of 1e, there were monster roles. They weren't at the top of the stat block as they are now, but they existed. One kind of monster was the magic using monster, a monster wizard essentially. These monsters ranked from the lowly kobold shaman up through the magic wielding dragon and the spell casting demon, but their apotheosis was the lich. It was the worst excesses of wizardly-ness combined with a bunch of undead stuff and it was truly horrible. However, if 4e nerfs magic, then the mountain of power upon which a lich stands is reduced to a hillock. You just simply don’t need a powerful undead wizard anymore because the game has done away with powerful wizards. They’re gone. Sorry. Complain if you like—many have, but they are gone. So, the undead version of the powerful wizard is like a buggy whip. I’d be more afraid of an undead warlord (in my campaign, one of the BBGs is a ghoul warlord and, boy oh boy, is he scary).
This inability of 4e to seriously deal with magic is completely apparent throughout NToH, again accentuated by a BBG who is supposed to be a powerful wizard. Ask yourselves the most simple question: why doesn’t the module deal with rituals? Where are the snares? Where are the traps set up around the ritual mechanic (like Lower Water)? Why are there no eyes of alarm or warning? Why doesn’t Acererak use all the various divination spells to figure out what’s going on with the PCs or, hey, vise versa. None of it is in this adventure as if even the left over magic system from earlier editions is simply impossible to deal with here. I read the adventures with a special eye towards the wizard’s duel that was OToH, where you cast spell X to deal with Acererak’s spell Y. There’s none of that. Near as I can figure, you could accidentally bypass the entire first adventure with Passwall. What do you say about that except, “huh?”
What’s interesting though is that Marmell and Gray didn’t let the hobbled magic system hobble them. They produce incredibly imaginative encounters that include magical elements. It’s just that the magic isn’t mechanical, it’s ad hoc. In such a system, the castles still fly, there just isn’t a mechanical system that makes the castle fly. The DM says it does, so it does. It’s what we sometimes call a campaign power. If the player says, “how can I get my castle to fly,” or “how can I get that castle to stop flying,” there is no page in any book to which they might be directed. It all has to be handled in game.
On the plus side, the effects are no longer limited by game mechanics in an ad hoc system, on the minus side…well…I don’t want a system that takes magic away from me, as a DM, because I can’t use it responsibly and then encourages me to just make it all up as I go along. Plus, the wizard’s duel becomes impossible because, while a DM can produce campaign powers at will, players have no access. Even there most powerful wizards are limited to DM caveat and what’s in (or increasingly not in) the book.
All of these problems stem from the demi-lich villain. Does the module have other problems, sure. They’re minor. I thought the Fey theme, when it appears, could have been otherwise ignored given how little it was developed. I felt that some of the monsters would become far more difficult opponents if they actively retreated, followed using stealth, and then sprung on the characters during later tense situations, but the main problems of the work, are really related to how much weight has to be placed on Acererak and how little weight the demi-lich can now sustain. Simply put, the demi-lich requires too much restructuring, redefinition, and game mechanical repair to serve as a BBG. NToH would have been significantly better if the villain were some unknown who, like Demogorgon with Dagon, was coached into the plot by Acererak. The incorporation of a secondary villain would require very few changes in the module at all, but it would make a BBG that fit the overarching plot better than the patient and waiting demi-lich. A secondary villain might even be made to stand at the top of a 4e power structure the way that a lich once did (whatever such a power structure would be; I’ve yet to really see something in 4e that really shines out as being truly powerful in the way the powerful magic user used to be).
That the writers of NToH felt compelled to include Acererak says as much about the third and final problem as I can say. This adventure would, of course, be just as good if it was called something else, so it is no defense to say that it must include Acererak because it is called ToH. But it is called ToH and not something else. As if 4e can create little original work (game designers: originality has always been something role players prize, more even than having an update of Spelljammer; just a suggestion).
The problem is that by calling it ToH, it automatically creates this point of comparison between D and D as it was originally conceived and D and D in its current version—a comparison that I’ve now attempted. It is upon this last point that the problems of edition are most revealed. How different NToH from OToH? How totally bizarre that they are products of the same RPG? It isn’t just that the philosophy of the game has shifted a bit, it has reversed polarities entirety. The good adventure has become, between 1st and 4th edition, an example of the worst design problems of game play, and I’d be willing to say that the 4e edition, with its ad hoc magic, would fail utterly in 1e. So, in some ways, I think these modules demonstrate thoroughly the very real source of D and D players’ essential fears about edition. After all, if this much can change from one edition to the next, why not more? Maybe the fifth edition’s ToH will have no monsters or spells because magic and monsters are removed from the system entirely. I don’t know. After the switch in 4e, I wouldn’t put money on anything. This kind of edition archaeology reveals that it isn’t just mechanics that is vulnerable to change, but everything: game conception, ideas about fair play and fun, basic ideas of what makes up the fantasy genre. The ToH reveals how shaky all of these pillars of support actually are.
Next time, Final installment: Becoming a better 4e DM through the navigation of NToH and its problems.
Sunday, August 22, 2010
Tomb of Horrors, Then and Now, part 3
The ideas presented in the New Tomb of Horrors, be they the mechanics that surround the magical nature of the tombs, the particular ideas that guide the individual encounters, the way that the various tomb adventures are brought together, the demands the module makes on the adventurers, or even just the artwork, it is all just plain brilliant. Absolutely creative, absolutely original--a real solid adventure for an edition that has been plagued by so-so showings. If it weren't for the 4e mechanic, this would be an adventure I would set next to any of the original S series modules and being a reader who routinely goes back and investigates the modules that I thought were great when I was 12 to make sure I still think so (I don't always), I would say that NToH, as it stands, easily beats the A series, Against the Giants, Dwellers, Ghost Tower, and most of the other modules that people cite as among the best (but not Dwellers, a special place in my heart for that one. Sorry).
Unfortunately, the new Tomb of Horrors is a lot like the original Tomb of Horrors except in reverse. The adventures should be the best written thus far for 4e. They have that potential, but they are utterly hobbled by the excesses of the 4e mechanic such that the adventures, despite their superb ideas, becomes almost a catalog of everything that is wrong with 4e adventure design. In general terms, the obvious and realistic are put on the back burner so as to make reasonable effects not happen, and unreasonable (but balanced effects) inevitable.
I am trying to write this as spoiler free as a I can, so please bear with me. When I do mention some part of the module, I will try to do so in vague enough terms that someone playing the module will not have the thing ruined for them. If you are a stickler for total surprise, I will write mild spoiler in front of any part of the adventure I cite even in vague terms. I promise.
That being said, mild spoiler alert:The sections for the DM occasionally explain that this room or that is integral to the big plan of Acererak which all but begs the question: what happens if the players destroy that room like The Who after a big show? No answer. The adventures all but require the character to pass through them in a linear fashion, but the maps clearly show side-doors. All this is based around the rather staid notion that every adventure=x amount of encounters=1 character level. If they go through the side-door and avoid half of the tomb then the characters won't get their level. In like manner, though some of the tombs have "guards," they never seem to think to warn their allies of invasion. Mmmm....Okay, I get it from a mechanical point of view. Facing two EL rooms at the same time is a bit of a spike, but still: why wouldn't the guards raise an alarm? Perhaps the worst excess of all this seems to be that no matter what the characters do in the first adventure, the second and subsequent adventures are EXACTLY the same. A little too much of that happening behind the DM's screen in 4e philosophy. We have now reached the point where we are not attempting to simulate D and D with video games but vise versa. As a result, there are options that just simply aren't listed up in our toolbar--but they are extraordinarily obvious choices that the adventure asks us to ignore. If the characters are being asked to attack a fortress, they ought to be allowed to determine their own way in, and they ought not be punished for not walking through the front door. This is, by the way, why I have done away with experience in my games, but that's another blog post. End Spoiler
Part of the difference here is that while Gygax designed OToH to take advantage of the most lethal aspects of the game to design Acererak's tomb, Marmell and Gray's attempt fumbles with the almost sycophantic way the non-combat aspects of the game force DMs to coddle their players into a kind of torpor. The adventures, because of the treasure parcel and experience system, railroad. Also, DCs are too low; the severity of the situations are not up to snuff for a regular adventure much less a death trap designed by Acererak and manifested in the various new dimensions of the D and D cosmology. The problem's go deeper, though, than just the usual complaints about difficulty. However, while I'm on the subject: Hello, game designers. Math 101: 10th level==+5, trained==+5, circumstance, racial, characteristic bonus==+3 (average), 4 characters helping==+6 (average), grand total=+19. Okay, DC 16s are laughable. Don't even bother writing them down. Hard is not a DC 20. It isn't even a DC 25. At some point, MILD SPOILER ALERTthe characters face someone/thing with a bluff of +16 with a long time to prepare his/her/its rouse. The characters have to beat it with either an Insight of 21 or a perception of 18. Why bother? Do NPCs not know how to take 10? Given the amount of preparation available in this particular encounter, I might have given a take 20. Take 5 is ridiculous. End Spoiler.
Note: I'm calling out game designers on this and not the adventure designers who are just following the DCs set up in other books. The problem here is that the rules are wrong, not the adventure, but of course, the adventure is now set to these rules. The elaborate descriptions of the death traps which invite excitement and joy don't mean very much when a character can defeat them by rolling a 2 or higher on an Arcana check.
Note also: I am not saying that the adventures in NToH are easy. This is a showcase module and if it highlights the problems of 4e, it also highlights the newest edition's most obvious victories. Combat in 4e is a pristine mechanic. It's like a show car's engine. It's just clean. And NToH, has taken that ultra-refined mechanic and turned it into an abattoir. I am willing to bet that I could TPK with almost every combat encounter listed in the adventure, and I think prevention of that TPK is almost totally reliant on the players showing the kind of intelligence in their tactical game play that OToH required in their exploration. It's just that I really don't think of ToH as being a combat module and so the switch took me a bit by surprise.
But this is not the only difference between OToH and NToH. The problems of OToH were unsolvable. NToH can be fixed. So, how to fix it?
(Yet still) More to Come
Unfortunately, the new Tomb of Horrors is a lot like the original Tomb of Horrors except in reverse. The adventures should be the best written thus far for 4e. They have that potential, but they are utterly hobbled by the excesses of the 4e mechanic such that the adventures, despite their superb ideas, becomes almost a catalog of everything that is wrong with 4e adventure design. In general terms, the obvious and realistic are put on the back burner so as to make reasonable effects not happen, and unreasonable (but balanced effects) inevitable.
I am trying to write this as spoiler free as a I can, so please bear with me. When I do mention some part of the module, I will try to do so in vague enough terms that someone playing the module will not have the thing ruined for them. If you are a stickler for total surprise, I will write mild spoiler in front of any part of the adventure I cite even in vague terms. I promise.
That being said, mild spoiler alert:The sections for the DM occasionally explain that this room or that is integral to the big plan of Acererak which all but begs the question: what happens if the players destroy that room like The Who after a big show? No answer. The adventures all but require the character to pass through them in a linear fashion, but the maps clearly show side-doors. All this is based around the rather staid notion that every adventure=x amount of encounters=1 character level. If they go through the side-door and avoid half of the tomb then the characters won't get their level. In like manner, though some of the tombs have "guards," they never seem to think to warn their allies of invasion. Mmmm....Okay, I get it from a mechanical point of view. Facing two EL rooms at the same time is a bit of a spike, but still: why wouldn't the guards raise an alarm? Perhaps the worst excess of all this seems to be that no matter what the characters do in the first adventure, the second and subsequent adventures are EXACTLY the same. A little too much of that happening behind the DM's screen in 4e philosophy. We have now reached the point where we are not attempting to simulate D and D with video games but vise versa. As a result, there are options that just simply aren't listed up in our toolbar--but they are extraordinarily obvious choices that the adventure asks us to ignore. If the characters are being asked to attack a fortress, they ought to be allowed to determine their own way in, and they ought not be punished for not walking through the front door. This is, by the way, why I have done away with experience in my games, but that's another blog post. End Spoiler
Part of the difference here is that while Gygax designed OToH to take advantage of the most lethal aspects of the game to design Acererak's tomb, Marmell and Gray's attempt fumbles with the almost sycophantic way the non-combat aspects of the game force DMs to coddle their players into a kind of torpor. The adventures, because of the treasure parcel and experience system, railroad. Also, DCs are too low; the severity of the situations are not up to snuff for a regular adventure much less a death trap designed by Acererak and manifested in the various new dimensions of the D and D cosmology. The problem's go deeper, though, than just the usual complaints about difficulty. However, while I'm on the subject: Hello, game designers. Math 101: 10th level==+5, trained==+5, circumstance, racial, characteristic bonus==+3 (average), 4 characters helping==+6 (average), grand total=+19. Okay, DC 16s are laughable. Don't even bother writing them down. Hard is not a DC 20. It isn't even a DC 25. At some point, MILD SPOILER ALERTthe characters face someone/thing with a bluff of +16 with a long time to prepare his/her/its rouse. The characters have to beat it with either an Insight of 21 or a perception of 18. Why bother? Do NPCs not know how to take 10? Given the amount of preparation available in this particular encounter, I might have given a take 20. Take 5 is ridiculous. End Spoiler.
Note: I'm calling out game designers on this and not the adventure designers who are just following the DCs set up in other books. The problem here is that the rules are wrong, not the adventure, but of course, the adventure is now set to these rules. The elaborate descriptions of the death traps which invite excitement and joy don't mean very much when a character can defeat them by rolling a 2 or higher on an Arcana check.
Note also: I am not saying that the adventures in NToH are easy. This is a showcase module and if it highlights the problems of 4e, it also highlights the newest edition's most obvious victories. Combat in 4e is a pristine mechanic. It's like a show car's engine. It's just clean. And NToH, has taken that ultra-refined mechanic and turned it into an abattoir. I am willing to bet that I could TPK with almost every combat encounter listed in the adventure, and I think prevention of that TPK is almost totally reliant on the players showing the kind of intelligence in their tactical game play that OToH required in their exploration. It's just that I really don't think of ToH as being a combat module and so the switch took me a bit by surprise.
But this is not the only difference between OToH and NToH. The problems of OToH were unsolvable. NToH can be fixed. So, how to fix it?
(Yet still) More to Come
Wednesday, August 11, 2010
Tomb of Horrors, Then and Now, Part 2
I ended the last blog post on this subject by stating that by 4e standards, the original Tomb of Horrors was the worst module ever made and wrote that OToH was essentially the best module ever made (or at least, the most iconic) for 1e. That's interesting, isn't it? I mean, it almost says everything about edition wars and the generation gap between 4e'ers and the Grognards. The best for the latter is the worst for the former.
But before the meditations get too deep, I want to clarify what I mean by the worst. First of all, Spoiler: I will be discussing the orginal ToH with specific references to the encounters in this article. I am letting you know. If you plan on playing that module and being surprised by it, do not read any further.
That said. Original Tomb of Horrors (OToH) teaches the players lessons and then punishes them for learning those lessons. Encounter 1 (THE VERY FIRST ENCOUNTER) is a room where, if you prod around with a 10' pole, you will be hit by 5d10 damage. The rest of the module all but requires constant prodding with a 10' pole, especially the great big sphere of annihilation. The first three encounters (two false entrances and one real entrance with a diversion, and said sphere) are likely to stymie characters for no good reason. You want into the tomb of horrors? You have to find the entrance. Sorry, it's hidden. Is it in room #1 where messing around causes 5d10 damage, room #2 where messing around causes you to be entombed until someone can cast enough "Stone to flesh" (disgusting!) to tunnel you out, or is it room #3 which is filled with totally deadly pits? Any guesses? Any? The entrance is behind a secret door down one of the deadly pits you've been trying to avoid--what? Wasn't that obvious enough?
And so the players are, sitting, being punished, essentially, for not understanding the strange logic of Gygax, for believing that the solution in room 2 has any bearing on the logic of room 3, in hoping that their spells will work as they should, and in one case, for not having the treasure table at the back of the MM memorized.
At one point there's a statue that turns into a four armed demon. Later, the characters find a similar statue. If they destroy the second statue (which is exactly what the players are likely to do), they are punished. Instead, they are supposed to put a gem in each of the statue's attached arms (one arm is on the ground) at which point it will crush the gems into dust. Do they do this once before they get their reward? That would make sense, but no. The statue gets three stones in its hands, crushes them, three more, crushes them, and then three more, and when it crushes these final three, an invisible gem of seeing appears in the final fourth arm. First off, who is going to keep putting gems in the things hands. Second, who's going to do it three times. Finally, who's going figure out that when all is said and done there's an invisible magic item in the fourth arm. Without the gem of seeing, you might as well go home: the adventure becomes impossible.
Let's be frank. The module is unplayable. It's just full of assumptions that are false, and it punishes players for not having a psychic link with the module's creator Gary Gygax. In terms of its Gygaxian biography, it was written relatively early in his career and it shows all the signs of an immature DM. It scoffs at the ignorance of players which it then uses to justify its sadism.
I forgive Gygax all this because he was, essentially, charting new waters every time he sat down to run a game. There wasn't really the same body of evidence about what players like and dislike about games as is available now. OToH promises to put the DM in the role of adversary, and it delivers on this promise. Perhaps I should add that, to his credit, his module is no less extreme then the new Tomb of Horrors--just in the opposite direction. OToH is ridiculously unaccommodating as a thing to be played. The new Tomb of Horrors is a pantomime lion (more on this in the next blog post).
But then, playability was never really one of the module's strengths, and quite frankly, it has no bearing on the module's success.
Wha, wha, what? Yes, I said it. OToH is the best of the 1e modules EVEN THOUGH it is utterly unplayable. In fact, one way you could find out, in all honesty, that one of your players had read the module was to simply try and run it. If they made it past the first three rooms, chances are they'd read the module already.
No, the real strength of OToH was in its capacity to challenge game play assumptions, especially regarding tricks and traps. Think about 1e for a moment. Think about the repertoire of spells available to players and what it meant to design a module that wouldn't allow a player to win by picking the right spell list. Imagine designing a module that wasn't combat centered when there wasn't ANY sort of skill system to speak of. There are three places in the module where the DM is asked to count slowly backwards from 10 to determine who is where when the trap goes off. That's McGuyver kind of stuff right there. That's Thomas Edison. Give the man credit, Gygax was a heck of an inventor.
We, the fledgling DMs reading OToH nodded all along thinking, "this is just great. This is precisely what I want to do with my games...except a lot less lethal." We learned at that extreme end of deadliness and came away understanding how to shape the non-combat portion of our games into sessions that became legendary. We liked the gem crushing statue, but we made it so that it crushed 3 gems instead of 9 (I'm using the statue as an example here) and the treasure, when it showed, would be visible. We learned how to manage player's spell books and how not to be surprised by astral travel and teleport without error. We took what was good about Acererak's tomb and we left out all that stuff that was over the top (we did similar things with Grimtooth's, by the way). OToH was boot camp.
And for players, has there ever been a better guide written since about how to explore a dungeon than OToH, a module that blatantly said, "if you aren't thinking of these kinds of things in your games then you aren't playing through exploration right" (and in that early Gygaxian and unforgiving way, "and thus, your character deserves to die")? OToH expanded the player's list of options to include the truly and meticulously careful world of serious dungeon exploration.
What went wrong? Well, isn't it obvious? If a bunch of us read OToH and thought, this is great but a bit too over the top, there were those who said this is great, period. There were many who read the work and simply decided that it represented exactly what a good D and D game ought to look like. They became the worst kind of killer DM: one who is justified by the game's designer. After all, if Gygax said it was okay, then it must have been okay. And if their players didn't like that kind of lethality, if they complained or became bored? Well, they needed to either play a different game or get better at this one.
At it's worst, OToH justified the worst excesses of bad DMing. It encouraged them not to tailor encounters to the player's power levels, it discouraged hints. It encouraged traps that murdered players outright, it discouraged teamwork. If 4e tells DMs to say "yes," Tomb of Horrors told its DMs to say, "no." At the same time, it told the players to min/max, to power game, and to dungeon crawl. Taken at face value, the module created horrible players and DMs that could not be dealt with within the game system as it stood.
Those of us who learned the lessons of OToH and then moderated them were baffled when 2nd edition came out, then 3rd, and now 4th. Looking back I wonder why any of us were surprised. Edition became the only way to deal with DMs and players who learned those same lessons and took them too seriously. The game could not teach these people moderation, so the rules began to increasingly prevent them. But the problem is that this moderation through rules does not just end. We who learned how to DM in moderation, found the game system itself increasingly telling us what could and what could not be allowed. The role of referee for the game increasingly fell to the game designers. So much so that now, OToH can be viewed only as a guidebook to what should not be done in a D and D game. It has gone from a positive example to a negative because it is easier to eliminate those tactics than to teach their use in moderation--easier to teach "always say yes," then to teach people when and why to say, "no;" easier to allow people to continue forward by succeeding in ridiculously easy skill checks then to have them sitting in front of those first three hallways trying to figure out which one has the secret door; easier to have them solve ridiculously easy patterns rather than trying to solve problems that were designed against cliche.
The problem, then, with the new Tomb of Horrors is that you can't make a module in the same philosophical vein as OToH, it would be like revising a view of the universe by Ptolemy according to Newton. Replace, sure. Revise, no way.
...But, and I think this is key, you can write a module that emerges from the game philosophy as it has since evolved and have it dofor 4e what OToH did for 1e. It will not be a great new Tomb of Horrors (it will not be impossible, it will not laugh as characters stumble into traps, it will not make the gem of seeing invisible), but if it provides players and DMs a chance to stretch their ideas of how to run a 4e game in the way that OToH once did for 1e, it would certainly be worth a careful examination. If it's playable this time, all the better. The new Tomb of Horrors has the benifit of playability. With a little help, it could be great.
More to come.
But before the meditations get too deep, I want to clarify what I mean by the worst. First of all, Spoiler: I will be discussing the orginal ToH with specific references to the encounters in this article. I am letting you know. If you plan on playing that module and being surprised by it, do not read any further.
That said. Original Tomb of Horrors (OToH) teaches the players lessons and then punishes them for learning those lessons. Encounter 1 (THE VERY FIRST ENCOUNTER) is a room where, if you prod around with a 10' pole, you will be hit by 5d10 damage. The rest of the module all but requires constant prodding with a 10' pole, especially the great big sphere of annihilation. The first three encounters (two false entrances and one real entrance with a diversion, and said sphere) are likely to stymie characters for no good reason. You want into the tomb of horrors? You have to find the entrance. Sorry, it's hidden. Is it in room #1 where messing around causes 5d10 damage, room #2 where messing around causes you to be entombed until someone can cast enough "Stone to flesh" (disgusting!) to tunnel you out, or is it room #3 which is filled with totally deadly pits? Any guesses? Any? The entrance is behind a secret door down one of the deadly pits you've been trying to avoid--what? Wasn't that obvious enough?
And so the players are, sitting, being punished, essentially, for not understanding the strange logic of Gygax, for believing that the solution in room 2 has any bearing on the logic of room 3, in hoping that their spells will work as they should, and in one case, for not having the treasure table at the back of the MM memorized.
At one point there's a statue that turns into a four armed demon. Later, the characters find a similar statue. If they destroy the second statue (which is exactly what the players are likely to do), they are punished. Instead, they are supposed to put a gem in each of the statue's attached arms (one arm is on the ground) at which point it will crush the gems into dust. Do they do this once before they get their reward? That would make sense, but no. The statue gets three stones in its hands, crushes them, three more, crushes them, and then three more, and when it crushes these final three, an invisible gem of seeing appears in the final fourth arm. First off, who is going to keep putting gems in the things hands. Second, who's going to do it three times. Finally, who's going figure out that when all is said and done there's an invisible magic item in the fourth arm. Without the gem of seeing, you might as well go home: the adventure becomes impossible.
Let's be frank. The module is unplayable. It's just full of assumptions that are false, and it punishes players for not having a psychic link with the module's creator Gary Gygax. In terms of its Gygaxian biography, it was written relatively early in his career and it shows all the signs of an immature DM. It scoffs at the ignorance of players which it then uses to justify its sadism.
I forgive Gygax all this because he was, essentially, charting new waters every time he sat down to run a game. There wasn't really the same body of evidence about what players like and dislike about games as is available now. OToH promises to put the DM in the role of adversary, and it delivers on this promise. Perhaps I should add that, to his credit, his module is no less extreme then the new Tomb of Horrors--just in the opposite direction. OToH is ridiculously unaccommodating as a thing to be played. The new Tomb of Horrors is a pantomime lion (more on this in the next blog post).
But then, playability was never really one of the module's strengths, and quite frankly, it has no bearing on the module's success.
Wha, wha, what? Yes, I said it. OToH is the best of the 1e modules EVEN THOUGH it is utterly unplayable. In fact, one way you could find out, in all honesty, that one of your players had read the module was to simply try and run it. If they made it past the first three rooms, chances are they'd read the module already.
No, the real strength of OToH was in its capacity to challenge game play assumptions, especially regarding tricks and traps. Think about 1e for a moment. Think about the repertoire of spells available to players and what it meant to design a module that wouldn't allow a player to win by picking the right spell list. Imagine designing a module that wasn't combat centered when there wasn't ANY sort of skill system to speak of. There are three places in the module where the DM is asked to count slowly backwards from 10 to determine who is where when the trap goes off. That's McGuyver kind of stuff right there. That's Thomas Edison. Give the man credit, Gygax was a heck of an inventor.
We, the fledgling DMs reading OToH nodded all along thinking, "this is just great. This is precisely what I want to do with my games...except a lot less lethal." We learned at that extreme end of deadliness and came away understanding how to shape the non-combat portion of our games into sessions that became legendary. We liked the gem crushing statue, but we made it so that it crushed 3 gems instead of 9 (I'm using the statue as an example here) and the treasure, when it showed, would be visible. We learned how to manage player's spell books and how not to be surprised by astral travel and teleport without error. We took what was good about Acererak's tomb and we left out all that stuff that was over the top (we did similar things with Grimtooth's, by the way). OToH was boot camp.
And for players, has there ever been a better guide written since about how to explore a dungeon than OToH, a module that blatantly said, "if you aren't thinking of these kinds of things in your games then you aren't playing through exploration right" (and in that early Gygaxian and unforgiving way, "and thus, your character deserves to die")? OToH expanded the player's list of options to include the truly and meticulously careful world of serious dungeon exploration.
What went wrong? Well, isn't it obvious? If a bunch of us read OToH and thought, this is great but a bit too over the top, there were those who said this is great, period. There were many who read the work and simply decided that it represented exactly what a good D and D game ought to look like. They became the worst kind of killer DM: one who is justified by the game's designer. After all, if Gygax said it was okay, then it must have been okay. And if their players didn't like that kind of lethality, if they complained or became bored? Well, they needed to either play a different game or get better at this one.
At it's worst, OToH justified the worst excesses of bad DMing. It encouraged them not to tailor encounters to the player's power levels, it discouraged hints. It encouraged traps that murdered players outright, it discouraged teamwork. If 4e tells DMs to say "yes," Tomb of Horrors told its DMs to say, "no." At the same time, it told the players to min/max, to power game, and to dungeon crawl. Taken at face value, the module created horrible players and DMs that could not be dealt with within the game system as it stood.
Those of us who learned the lessons of OToH and then moderated them were baffled when 2nd edition came out, then 3rd, and now 4th. Looking back I wonder why any of us were surprised. Edition became the only way to deal with DMs and players who learned those same lessons and took them too seriously. The game could not teach these people moderation, so the rules began to increasingly prevent them. But the problem is that this moderation through rules does not just end. We who learned how to DM in moderation, found the game system itself increasingly telling us what could and what could not be allowed. The role of referee for the game increasingly fell to the game designers. So much so that now, OToH can be viewed only as a guidebook to what should not be done in a D and D game. It has gone from a positive example to a negative because it is easier to eliminate those tactics than to teach their use in moderation--easier to teach "always say yes," then to teach people when and why to say, "no;" easier to allow people to continue forward by succeeding in ridiculously easy skill checks then to have them sitting in front of those first three hallways trying to figure out which one has the secret door; easier to have them solve ridiculously easy patterns rather than trying to solve problems that were designed against cliche.
The problem, then, with the new Tomb of Horrors is that you can't make a module in the same philosophical vein as OToH, it would be like revising a view of the universe by Ptolemy according to Newton. Replace, sure. Revise, no way.
...But, and I think this is key, you can write a module that emerges from the game philosophy as it has since evolved and have it dofor 4e what OToH did for 1e. It will not be a great new Tomb of Horrors (it will not be impossible, it will not laugh as characters stumble into traps, it will not make the gem of seeing invisible), but if it provides players and DMs a chance to stretch their ideas of how to run a 4e game in the way that OToH once did for 1e, it would certainly be worth a careful examination. If it's playable this time, all the better. The new Tomb of Horrors has the benifit of playability. With a little help, it could be great.
More to come.
Tomb of Horrors, Then and Now part 1
Reviewing a re-imagining of Tomb of Horrors is a bit complicated…and it doesn’t help that the modules been out for some weeks now (or years, depending on which version of Tomb of Horrorsyou’re reading). The task of writing this review has sort of opened up, a kind of question of game philosophy, game direction, and game history, with an emphasis in all three on motive. I say this because I think that ToH is perhaps the most iconic of Dungeons and Dragons modules. It, more than any other module, demonstrated to enterprising and imaginative DMs the possibilities for adventures available within the game.
Now, that’s a bold statement. So, let me back this up. Obviously, the series of modules devoted to the drow and to the slave lords are oft cited as iconic, as is Keep on the Borderlands (which I think is the most recognizable adventure of all), but each of these adventures concentrated on immersion, story line…the primary thing you remember about these adventures was not that they tested the boundaries of what one could do with the Dungeons and Dragons game but provided good standard for a normal D and D adventure.
Let me try this another way, most adventures taught DMs what an adventure in a fantasy setting ought to look like (dungeon crawl, cavern exploration, fortress assault, encounter with evil civilization, etc.). The S series of modules did something more. They actively stretched the bounds of the DMs function in the game. They acted as an example of what you could do in D and D that might otherwise have escaped your attention. Lost Caverns of Tsojcath said to DMs, “hey, this is what an adventure looks like when the majority of the creatures are custom made.” It even instructed DMs a bit about how to create custom creatures from thin air and make them balanced to their encounter. Mind you, this kind of thinking was in its earliest stages: it provided examples, not a rubric for game mechanics—but it was like designer’s permission to start making custom monsters.
White Plume (the lamest of the S series) basically explained how to put the menagerie of D and D beasties all in one place, how to create encounters from extremely disparate creatures. Outside the White Plume Philosophy, you’re in a module based on giants, and you fight giants. You’re in a module based on slavers and you fight slavers. In White Plume, the next room could as easily have had a dragon as a treant and White Plume provided a great example of how such an adventure could be designed logically.
Expedition to the BarrierPeaks stretched the definition of fantasy setting as far as it could go by changing the dungeon into a space ship. Forget game balance. Expedition balanced itself against itself. The weapons it gave out were fair only inside the module. Outside the shell of the ship, a character with any of those weapons was unstoppable. Ignoring that for a moment though, Expedition was the module that really said that anything goes, and meant it.
…But more than any others stood the Tomb of Horrors, S1, the first of the series which said to the clever DM, the puzzler and the trap maker, this is how you do it. As far as the craziness of 1st edition is concerned, it is Tomb of Horrors that set the standard for setting up a module that would challenge the veteran adventurer and the power gamer alike.
The thing is, though, Tomb of Horrors is, by all that is standard game philosophy in 4e, the worst module ever made. It is horrible from the point of view of 4e because it does EVERYTHING that 4e tells you that you should never do as a DM. One must ask, then, how does one moves from the best 1e module (and the worst 4e module) to what is, in my opinion, a shoddy remake (because a remake of Tomb of Horrors is, otherwise, impossible) and yet, still produce the best 4e module thus far? By answering this question in regards to the iconic status of ToH, I would like to try to explain the preconceptions of the various editions, and why edition was ever needed in the first place.
Stay tuned, more to come…
Now, that’s a bold statement. So, let me back this up. Obviously, the series of modules devoted to the drow and to the slave lords are oft cited as iconic, as is Keep on the Borderlands (which I think is the most recognizable adventure of all), but each of these adventures concentrated on immersion, story line…the primary thing you remember about these adventures was not that they tested the boundaries of what one could do with the Dungeons and Dragons game but provided good standard for a normal D and D adventure.
Let me try this another way, most adventures taught DMs what an adventure in a fantasy setting ought to look like (dungeon crawl, cavern exploration, fortress assault, encounter with evil civilization, etc.). The S series of modules did something more. They actively stretched the bounds of the DMs function in the game. They acted as an example of what you could do in D and D that might otherwise have escaped your attention. Lost Caverns of Tsojcath said to DMs, “hey, this is what an adventure looks like when the majority of the creatures are custom made.” It even instructed DMs a bit about how to create custom creatures from thin air and make them balanced to their encounter. Mind you, this kind of thinking was in its earliest stages: it provided examples, not a rubric for game mechanics—but it was like designer’s permission to start making custom monsters.
White Plume (the lamest of the S series) basically explained how to put the menagerie of D and D beasties all in one place, how to create encounters from extremely disparate creatures. Outside the White Plume Philosophy, you’re in a module based on giants, and you fight giants. You’re in a module based on slavers and you fight slavers. In White Plume, the next room could as easily have had a dragon as a treant and White Plume provided a great example of how such an adventure could be designed logically.
Expedition to the BarrierPeaks stretched the definition of fantasy setting as far as it could go by changing the dungeon into a space ship. Forget game balance. Expedition balanced itself against itself. The weapons it gave out were fair only inside the module. Outside the shell of the ship, a character with any of those weapons was unstoppable. Ignoring that for a moment though, Expedition was the module that really said that anything goes, and meant it.
…But more than any others stood the Tomb of Horrors, S1, the first of the series which said to the clever DM, the puzzler and the trap maker, this is how you do it. As far as the craziness of 1st edition is concerned, it is Tomb of Horrors that set the standard for setting up a module that would challenge the veteran adventurer and the power gamer alike.
The thing is, though, Tomb of Horrors is, by all that is standard game philosophy in 4e, the worst module ever made. It is horrible from the point of view of 4e because it does EVERYTHING that 4e tells you that you should never do as a DM. One must ask, then, how does one moves from the best 1e module (and the worst 4e module) to what is, in my opinion, a shoddy remake (because a remake of Tomb of Horrors is, otherwise, impossible) and yet, still produce the best 4e module thus far? By answering this question in regards to the iconic status of ToH, I would like to try to explain the preconceptions of the various editions, and why edition was ever needed in the first place.
Stay tuned, more to come…
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
