Sunday, August 22, 2010

Tomb of Horrors, Then and Now, part 3

The ideas presented in the New Tomb of Horrors, be they the mechanics that surround the magical nature of the tombs, the particular ideas that guide the individual encounters, the way that the various tomb adventures are brought together, the demands the module makes on the adventurers, or even just the artwork, it is all just plain brilliant. Absolutely creative, absolutely original--a real solid adventure for an edition that has been plagued by so-so showings. If it weren't for the 4e mechanic, this would be an adventure I would set next to any of the original S series modules and being a reader who routinely goes back and investigates the modules that I thought were great when I was 12 to make sure I still think so (I don't always), I would say that NToH, as it stands, easily beats the A series, Against the Giants, Dwellers, Ghost Tower, and most of the other modules that people cite as among the best (but not Dwellers, a special place in my heart for that one. Sorry).

Unfortunately, the new Tomb of Horrors is a lot like the original Tomb of Horrors except in reverse. The adventures should be the best written thus far for 4e. They have that potential, but they are utterly hobbled by the excesses of the 4e mechanic such that the adventures, despite their superb ideas, becomes almost a catalog of everything that is wrong with 4e adventure design. In general terms, the obvious and realistic are put on the back burner so as to make reasonable effects not happen, and unreasonable (but balanced effects) inevitable.

I am trying to write this as spoiler free as a I can, so please bear with me. When I do mention some part of the module, I will try to do so in vague enough terms that someone playing the module will not have the thing ruined for them. If you are a stickler for total surprise, I will write mild spoiler in front of any part of the adventure I cite even in vague terms. I promise.

That being said, mild spoiler alert:The sections for the DM occasionally explain that this room or that is integral to the big plan of Acererak which all but begs the question: what happens if the players destroy that room like The Who after a big show? No answer. The adventures all but require the character to pass through them in a linear fashion, but the maps clearly show side-doors. All this is based around the rather staid notion that every adventure=x amount of encounters=1 character level. If they go through the side-door and avoid half of the tomb then the characters won't get their level. In like manner, though some of the tombs have "guards," they never seem to think to warn their allies of invasion. Mmmm....Okay, I get it from a mechanical point of view. Facing two EL rooms at the same time is a bit of a spike, but still: why wouldn't the guards raise an alarm? Perhaps the worst excess of all this seems to be that no matter what the characters do in the first adventure, the second and subsequent adventures are EXACTLY the same. A little too much of that happening behind the DM's screen in 4e philosophy. We have now reached the point where we are not attempting to simulate D and D with video games but vise versa. As a result, there are options that just simply aren't listed up in our toolbar--but they are extraordinarily obvious choices that the adventure asks us to ignore. If the characters are being asked to attack a fortress, they ought to be allowed to determine their own way in, and they ought not be punished for not walking through the front door. This is, by the way, why I have done away with experience in my games, but that's another blog post. End Spoiler

Part of the difference here is that while Gygax designed OToH to take advantage of the most lethal aspects of the game to design Acererak's tomb, Marmell and Gray's attempt fumbles with the almost sycophantic way the non-combat aspects of the game force DMs to coddle their players into a kind of torpor. The adventures, because of the treasure parcel and experience system, railroad. Also, DCs are too low; the severity of the situations are not up to snuff for a regular adventure much less a death trap designed by Acererak and manifested in the various new dimensions of the D and D cosmology. The problem's go deeper, though, than just the usual complaints about difficulty. However, while I'm on the subject: Hello, game designers. Math 101: 10th level==+5, trained==+5, circumstance, racial, characteristic bonus==+3 (average), 4 characters helping==+6 (average), grand total=+19. Okay, DC 16s are laughable. Don't even bother writing them down. Hard is not a DC 20. It isn't even a DC 25. At some point, MILD SPOILER ALERTthe characters face someone/thing with a bluff of +16 with a long time to prepare his/her/its rouse. The characters have to beat it with either an Insight of 21 or a perception of 18. Why bother? Do NPCs not know how to take 10? Given the amount of preparation available in this particular encounter, I might have given a take 20. Take 5 is ridiculous. End Spoiler.

Note: I'm calling out game designers on this and not the adventure designers who are just following the DCs set up in other books. The problem here is that the rules are wrong, not the adventure, but of course, the adventure is now set to these rules. The elaborate descriptions of the death traps which invite excitement and joy don't mean very much when a character can defeat them by rolling a 2 or higher on an Arcana check.

Note also: I am not saying that the adventures in NToH are easy. This is a showcase module and if it highlights the problems of 4e, it also highlights the newest edition's most obvious victories. Combat in 4e is a pristine mechanic. It's like a show car's engine. It's just clean. And NToH, has taken that ultra-refined mechanic and turned it into an abattoir. I am willing to bet that I could TPK with almost every combat encounter listed in the adventure, and I think prevention of that TPK is almost totally reliant on the players showing the kind of intelligence in their tactical game play that OToH required in their exploration. It's just that I really don't think of ToH as being a combat module and so the switch took me a bit by surprise.
But this is not the only difference between OToH and NToH. The problems of OToH were unsolvable. NToH can be fixed. So, how to fix it?

(Yet still) More to Come

No comments:

Post a Comment