Wednesday, August 11, 2010

Tomb of Horrors, Then and Now, Part 2

I ended the last blog post on this subject by stating that by 4e standards, the original Tomb of Horrors was the worst module ever made and wrote that OToH was essentially the best module ever made (or at least, the most iconic) for 1e. That's interesting, isn't it? I mean, it almost says everything about edition wars and the generation gap between 4e'ers and the Grognards. The best for the latter is the worst for the former.

But before the meditations get too deep, I want to clarify what I mean by the worst. First of all, Spoiler: I will be discussing the orginal ToH with specific references to the encounters in this article. I am letting you know. If you plan on playing that module and being surprised by it, do not read any further.

That said. Original Tomb of Horrors (OToH) teaches the players lessons and then punishes them for learning those lessons. Encounter 1 (THE VERY FIRST ENCOUNTER) is a room where, if you prod around with a 10' pole, you will be hit by 5d10 damage. The rest of the module all but requires constant prodding with a 10' pole, especially the great big sphere of annihilation. The first three encounters (two false entrances and one real entrance with a diversion, and said sphere) are likely to stymie characters for no good reason. You want into the tomb of horrors? You have to find the entrance. Sorry, it's hidden. Is it in room #1 where messing around causes 5d10 damage, room #2 where messing around causes you to be entombed until someone can cast enough "Stone to flesh" (disgusting!) to tunnel you out, or is it room #3 which is filled with totally deadly pits? Any guesses? Any? The entrance is behind a secret door down one of the deadly pits you've been trying to avoid--what? Wasn't that obvious enough?

And so the players are, sitting, being punished, essentially, for not understanding the strange logic of Gygax, for believing that the solution in room 2 has any bearing on the logic of room 3, in hoping that their spells will work as they should, and in one case, for not having the treasure table at the back of the MM memorized.

At one point there's a statue that turns into a four armed demon. Later, the characters find a similar statue. If they destroy the second statue (which is exactly what the players are likely to do), they are punished. Instead, they are supposed to put a gem in each of the statue's attached arms (one arm is on the ground) at which point it will crush the gems into dust. Do they do this once before they get their reward? That would make sense, but no. The statue gets three stones in its hands, crushes them, three more, crushes them, and then three more, and when it crushes these final three, an invisible gem of seeing appears in the final fourth arm. First off, who is going to keep putting gems in the things hands. Second, who's going to do it three times. Finally, who's going figure out that when all is said and done there's an invisible magic item in the fourth arm. Without the gem of seeing, you might as well go home: the adventure becomes impossible.

Let's be frank. The module is unplayable. It's just full of assumptions that are false, and it punishes players for not having a psychic link with the module's creator Gary Gygax. In terms of its Gygaxian biography, it was written relatively early in his career and it shows all the signs of an immature DM. It scoffs at the ignorance of players which it then uses to justify its sadism.
I forgive Gygax all this because he was, essentially, charting new waters every time he sat down to run a game. There wasn't really the same body of evidence about what players like and dislike about games as is available now. OToH promises to put the DM in the role of adversary, and it delivers on this promise. Perhaps I should add that, to his credit, his module is no less extreme then the new Tomb of Horrors--just in the opposite direction. OToH is ridiculously unaccommodating as a thing to be played. The new Tomb of Horrors is a pantomime lion (more on this in the next blog post).

But then, playability was never really one of the module's strengths, and quite frankly, it has no bearing on the module's success.

Wha, wha, what? Yes, I said it. OToH is the best of the 1e modules EVEN THOUGH it is utterly unplayable. In fact, one way you could find out, in all honesty, that one of your players had read the module was to simply try and run it. If they made it past the first three rooms, chances are they'd read the module already.

No, the real strength of OToH was in its capacity to challenge game play assumptions, especially regarding tricks and traps. Think about 1e for a moment. Think about the repertoire of spells available to players and what it meant to design a module that wouldn't allow a player to win by picking the right spell list. Imagine designing a module that wasn't combat centered when there wasn't ANY sort of skill system to speak of. There are three places in the module where the DM is asked to count slowly backwards from 10 to determine who is where when the trap goes off. That's McGuyver kind of stuff right there. That's Thomas Edison. Give the man credit, Gygax was a heck of an inventor.

We, the fledgling DMs reading OToH nodded all along thinking, "this is just great. This is precisely what I want to do with my games...except a lot less lethal." We learned at that extreme end of deadliness and came away understanding how to shape the non-combat portion of our games into sessions that became legendary. We liked the gem crushing statue, but we made it so that it crushed 3 gems instead of 9 (I'm using the statue as an example here) and the treasure, when it showed, would be visible. We learned how to manage player's spell books and how not to be surprised by astral travel and teleport without error. We took what was good about Acererak's tomb and we left out all that stuff that was over the top (we did similar things with Grimtooth's, by the way). OToH was boot camp.

And for players, has there ever been a better guide written since about how to explore a dungeon than OToH, a module that blatantly said, "if you aren't thinking of these kinds of things in your games then you aren't playing through exploration right" (and in that early Gygaxian and unforgiving way, "and thus, your character deserves to die")? OToH expanded the player's list of options to include the truly and meticulously careful world of serious dungeon exploration.
What went wrong? Well, isn't it obvious? If a bunch of us read OToH and thought, this is great but a bit too over the top, there were those who said this is great, period. There were many who read the work and simply decided that it represented exactly what a good D and D game ought to look like. They became the worst kind of killer DM: one who is justified by the game's designer. After all, if Gygax said it was okay, then it must have been okay. And if their players didn't like that kind of lethality, if they complained or became bored? Well, they needed to either play a different game or get better at this one.

At it's worst, OToH justified the worst excesses of bad DMing. It encouraged them not to tailor encounters to the player's power levels, it discouraged hints. It encouraged traps that murdered players outright, it discouraged teamwork. If 4e tells DMs to say "yes," Tomb of Horrors told its DMs to say, "no." At the same time, it told the players to min/max, to power game, and to dungeon crawl. Taken at face value, the module created horrible players and DMs that could not be dealt with within the game system as it stood.

Those of us who learned the lessons of OToH and then moderated them were baffled when 2nd edition came out, then 3rd, and now 4th. Looking back I wonder why any of us were surprised. Edition became the only way to deal with DMs and players who learned those same lessons and took them too seriously. The game could not teach these people moderation, so the rules began to increasingly prevent them. But the problem is that this moderation through rules does not just end. We who learned how to DM in moderation, found the game system itself increasingly telling us what could and what could not be allowed. The role of referee for the game increasingly fell to the game designers. So much so that now, OToH can be viewed only as a guidebook to what should not be done in a D and D game. It has gone from a positive example to a negative because it is easier to eliminate those tactics than to teach their use in moderation--easier to teach "always say yes," then to teach people when and why to say, "no;" easier to allow people to continue forward by succeeding in ridiculously easy skill checks then to have them sitting in front of those first three hallways trying to figure out which one has the secret door; easier to have them solve ridiculously easy patterns rather than trying to solve problems that were designed against cliche.

The problem, then, with the new Tomb of Horrors is that you can't make a module in the same philosophical vein as OToH, it would be like revising a view of the universe by Ptolemy according to Newton. Replace, sure. Revise, no way.

...But, and I think this is key, you can write a module that emerges from the game philosophy as it has since evolved and have it dofor 4e what OToH did for 1e. It will not be a great new Tomb of Horrors (it will not be impossible, it will not laugh as characters stumble into traps, it will not make the gem of seeing invisible), but if it provides players and DMs a chance to stretch their ideas of how to run a 4e game in the way that OToH once did for 1e, it would certainly be worth a careful examination. If it's playable this time, all the better. The new Tomb of Horrors has the benifit of playability. With a little help, it could be great.

More to come.

1 comment:

  1. You made me pull out the module and read through it. I still have S3 as well.

    ReplyDelete