Friday, September 4, 2009

The Nature of Magic

One of the things I hate about Dungeons and Dragons, and this has been true about every edition, is that magic essentially boils down to a rather ennumeratable series of powers that all work, more or less, the same. In other words, magic becomes spells, and while there are magic items too, most of those are either spells (or work in very nearly the same way) or buffs to already existing abilities. What magic chiefly lacks in this scheme is its element of mystery. I don't think that magic should be wholly mysterious. Obviously, the ability to play magic users and spell casters means that somewhere in all this a game system must arise, but it really feels that beyond these class abilities, magic simply doesn't exist.

Let me be more specific. What I think is missing is the element of magic that one might think of as superstition. The villagers are never right with their wive's tales and stupid charms. The woman down the road isn't a witch. She's either a misunderstood magic user or a hag in disguise. If you step on a crack, it most certainly won't break your mama's back. I like to think of magic in terms of energy--like radioactivity in a post-apocalyptic game or the bad stuff that always seems to creep up around untimely deaths in horror movies. In short, I want the old temple to really be cursed. I want mentioning the name of the mayor, recently gone missing, to actually be dangerous, and I want the act of lending help to those they say are cursed by the Gods to actually be a bad idea.

The game mechanic I'm using to make this world come to life is the ruleset surrounding diseases. However, instead of diseases, I'm handing out curses. Remove Curse is used to get rid of the stuff in exactly the same way as "Treat Disease" and the curses are put in place sort of naturally. If you remove gear from the recently killed on a fresh battlefield, then you may catch a curse.

I recommend that if you have the same problem with the game that I had, you utilize the technique, it's amazing how much it changes the nature of mystery in a game.

No comments:

Post a Comment